Vasanas — Are We Carrying More Than We Remember?
An enquiry into tendencies, Karma, multiple lives and what may continue beyond one lifetime.
A Note to the Reader
These conversations are an exploration by a questioning student — me. They use a conversational format inspired by Tibetan Buddhist monastic debate, not as a reproduction of formal debate practice, but as a way of examining ideas, questioning assumptions and learning through enquiry.
The thoughts expressed by the two students are not presented as authoritative interpretations or established philosophical conclusions. They may draw upon traditional teachings, personal understanding, observation and speculation. Where a thought is a personal musing rather than a recognised teaching, it will be identified as such.
The intention is not to establish who is right, but to keep asking, listening, examining and learning.
Under the tree
The seated monk was once again beneath the tree, absorbed in thought. The other monk approached, stood before him, clapped his hands and waited.
Standing Monk: We ended our previous conversation with a question. If our likes, dislikes and habitual responses are influenced by underlying tendencies called Vasanas, where do these tendencies come from? Are they formed during this lifetime, or do we bring them with us?
The seated monk looked up.
Seated Monk: Let us begin with what we can observe. Our experiences, thoughts, choices and actions influence the way we respond to the world. Repeated ways of thinking and acting can become familiar patterns. Some of these patterns are easily recognised; others operate beneath our awareness.
Standing Monk: Then Vasanas are simply learned habits?
Seated Monk: Not quite. In Vedantic teaching, Vasanas are deeper underlying tendencies or conditioning that influence the direction of our thoughts, desires and actions. A habit may be one visible expression of a Vasana, but the tendency itself can be much deeper.
Standing Monk: Where do these tendencies reside?
Seated Monk: Here we need to understand the three Shariras described in Vedanta: Sthula Sharira, Sukshma Sharira and Karana Sharira.
The Sthula Sharira is the gross or physical body. The Sukshma Sharira is the subtle body, through which we experience and respond using our mind, intellect, senses and vital functions. The Karana Sharira is the causal body, associated with the unmanifest condition and the deep-rooted ignorance and Vasanas that condition our individual personality.
Standing Monk: Are you saying that Vasanas belong to the Karana Sharira?
Seated Monk: Yes. In the explanation given by Pujya Gurudev Swami Chinmayananda, Vasanas are the deep-rooted conditioning at the causal level. They influence the intellect, which generates desires; the mind responds with thoughts and emotions; and these eventually find expression through our senses and physical actions.
Standing Monk: So the causal body influences the subtle body, and the subtle body expresses itself through the gross body?
Seated Monk: That is a useful way to understand the relationship. The causal level provides the underlying conditioning; the subtle body is the instrument through which that conditioning expresses itself as thought, feeling and desire; and the gross body becomes the instrument of physical action.
Standing Monk: Then are all these Vasanas acquired during this lifetime?
Seated Monk: Our present experiences, thoughts and actions certainly reinforce and shape our tendencies. But Vedanta also asks us to consider something beyond this lifetime. If the individual experiences repeated births, the tendencies associated with that individuality cannot be explained only by the experiences of the present body.
Standing Monk: You mean that the person we are today may be carrying tendencies from lives we do not remember?
Seated Monk: That is the traditional understanding of continuity through Samsara. The individual Jiva undergoes successive embodiments, and the tendencies and Karma associated with it influence the nature of its experiences.
Standing Monk: But when this physical body dies, what exactly continues? Surely the body cannot carry these tendencies with it.
Seated Monk: Correct. The Sthula Sharira is left behind. In the Chinmaya explanation, the Sukshma Sharira continues after its separation from the physical body. The individual personality, with its thought-patterns and conditioning, continues through the process of rebirth.
Standing Monk: Then does the Atman travel from one body to another?
Seated Monk: No. This is an important distinction. The Atman, the eternal Self, does not travel or undergo birth and death. It is the Jiva — the individual experiencer associated with the subtle body and its conditioning — that undergoes the cycle of births and deaths.
Standing Monk: Then what is the relationship between the Karana Sharira and the Sukshma Sharira after death?
Seated Monk: The causal conditioning remains the underlying source of the individual tendencies, while the subtle body is the continuing instrument of individual experience. We should not imagine these as two physical containers carrying little packets of memories. They are different levels of the Vedantic explanation of individual existence.
Standing Monk: And what determines the circumstances of the next birth?
Seated Monk: According to the traditional understanding of Karma and rebirth, past actions, desires and tendencies influence the nature of future experience. Pujya Gurudev, while explaining the Bhagavad Gita, discusses how the predominant Gunas and the texture of our thoughts influence the field in which the individual tendencies find expression.
Standing Monk: So our next birth is shaped by the tendencies we carry?
Seated Monk: That is the traditional explanation. But we should be careful not to reduce the entire law of Karma to a simple formula. The relationship between Karma, Vasanas, Gunas and rebirth is more intricate than that.
Standing Monk: Then let me ask another question. If these tendencies influence the circumstances into which we are born, could they also have a connection with our natal chart?
The seated monk paused.
Seated Monk: That brings us to Jyotisha. In traditional astrology, the planetary positions at birth are interpreted in relation to Karma, circumstances and tendencies. Could the natal chart offer us a symbolic picture of the tendencies with which an individual begins this lifetime?
Standing Monk: Are you saying that our birth chart records our Vasanas?
Seated Monk: No. We have not established that. Jyotisha is a separate field of traditional knowledge, and we should not confuse its interpretations with the Vedantic explanation of the three Shariras. Whether a natal chart can reveal anything about the Vasanas associated with an individual is a question we may explore, but we should not present it as an established Chinmaya teaching or as a proven fact.
Standing Monk: Then perhaps the life we experience is shaped by more than the circumstances we see around us. There may be underlying tendencies that influence how we meet the world.
Seated Monk: Indeed. And that brings us back to the BMI Chart. We experience the world through our Body, Mind and Intellect. Our Perceiver, Feeler and Thinker encounter Objects, Emotions and Thoughts. The Vasanas influence the direction of our thoughts, desires and responses.
Standing Monk: So the BMI Chart helps us understand how these underlying tendencies express themselves in everyday experience?
Seated Monk: Yes. The chart helps us observe the relationship between our equipment, our experiences and the tendencies that condition our responses. It brings the larger Vedantic ideas into the field of everyday life.
Standing Monk: But if our responses are shaped by Vasanas, are we simply repeating what has already been set in motion?
The seated monk smiled.
Seated Monk: Now you are asking about destiny and freedom. If our tendencies influence our choices, are we helpless before them? Can we discipline the mind, change the quality of our thoughts and gradually transform our responses?
Standing Monk: But if the Vasanas are so deeply rooted, how can we change them?
Seated Monk: This is where spiritual practice becomes important. Vedanta does not ask us merely to observe our tendencies and accept them as inevitable. It gives us ways to discipline our senses, purify our thoughts, improve the quality of our actions and develop discrimination. Through such practice, the hold of our conditioning can be reduced.
Standing Monk: And is that enough to bring about realisation?
Seated Monk: We must distinguish between changing our tendencies and knowing our true nature. Spiritual practices help prepare and purify the mind. But Self-knowledge is not simply the result of acquiring better habits. It is the recognition that our real nature is not the body, mind or intellect, but the Consciousness that illumines them.
Standing Monk: Then even if we change our Vasanas, we have not necessarily realised the Self?
Seated Monk: Correct. We may become calmer, more disciplined and less driven by our tendencies, but the fundamental question remains: Who am I, beyond this changing personality?
Standing Monk: And perhaps an even larger question: if our lives are influenced by past Karma, is our journey towards realisation also already destined?
The seated monk looked towards the trees.
Seated Monk: We have travelled quite far from the simple question of where our likes and dislikes come from. Perhaps we should pause here. We have yet to understand the relationship between destiny, individual effort and the possibility of freedom.
The standing monk nodded. He had another question, but decided to carry it with him for now.
What We Have Understood
In this conversation, we have begun to explore:
- Vasanas as deep-rooted tendencies or conditioning that influence our thoughts, desires and actions.
- The relationship between present experiences and the reinforcement of our tendencies.
- The three Shariras: Sthula, Sukshma and Karana.
- The association of Vasanas with the causal body in the Chinmaya explanation.
- The role of the subtle body in the continuity of individual experience beyond physical death.
- The distinction between Atman and Jiva in the context of rebirth.
- The traditional relationship between Karma, Gunas, Vasanas and future embodiments.
- The possible relationship between Jyotisha and individual tendencies, which remains an open question in our enquiry.
- The way Vasanas influence our experience through the BMI.
These ideas are connected, but they belong to different levels of explanation. We must be careful not to treat every proposed connection as an established fact.
The Thread We Are Following
Our enquiry is beginning to take shape:
Vasanas → Karma and Samsara → Birth and circumstances → BMI and experience → Self-enquiry and realisation
This is a working map, not a proven chain of cause and effect. Each connection raises questions that we will examine as we proceed.
Where Do We Go From Here?
If our tendencies influence the way we perceive, feel, think and act, are we bound to repeat them?
Can Vasanas be understood, purified or exhausted? Does spiritual practice give us the freedom to respond differently? And if our lives are influenced by past Karma, where does individual effort enter?
Perhaps our next conversation should begin with this question:
Are we merely living out our tendencies, or can we become aware of them and change the way we live?
Further Reading and References
The following resources have informed our enquiry. They include explanations by Pujya Gurudev Swami Chinmayananda and study material from Chinmaya Mission and the Chinmaya International Foundation.
1. Where Do Vasanas Fit In? — Chinmaya International Foundation
Swami Vidyaranya’s Panchadashee – 03: Pancha Kosha Viveka, reflections by Swami Gurubhaktananda, Chinmaya Home-Study Course.
This is particularly relevant to our discussion. It examines the relationship between Vasanas, the three Shariras and the five Koshas. It also explores why assigning Vasanas to just one body or sheath may not provide a complete explanation.
Read the Chinmaya International Foundation study material (PDF)
2. Not for Idle Curiosity — Q&A with Pujya Gurudev Swami Chinmayananda
Originally published in Tapovan Prasad (1988), reproduced in Chinmaya Mission West News, November 2015.
Gurudev discusses Vasanas, rebirth, the circumstances of birth and the importance of exhausting existing tendencies without creating further ones.
Read the Chinmaya Mission West newsletter (PDF)
3. Striving — Pujya Gurudev Swami Chinmayananda
Published in Chinmaya Mission West News, September 2010.
This article explores how thoughts and actions leave impressions, how repeated patterns reinforce Vasanas, and how spiritual practice, devotion and selfless action help transform the mind.
Read the article in the Chinmaya Mission newsletter (PDF)
4. Vedanta, the Science of Life: Understanding Human Nature — Swami Chinmayananda
Central Chinmaya Mission Trust, 1979.
A broader study of Vedanta and human nature, including the relationship between the body, mind, intellect, desires, Karma and Vasanas.
View the bibliographic details
These references are offered as starting points for further study. Our conversations remain an independent exercise in questioning and understanding, and should not be mistaken for a substitute for systematic study of Vedanta under a qualified teacher.
Credit: Convo with Goosey (AI Powered ChatGPT)
