Conversation 1 of 8: Where Do We Begin?
An exploration of Vedanta through questions, pauses and conversation.
A note about these conversations
In this series, we follow two monks in conversation. One sits beneath a tree, while the other approaches, stands before him, claps his hands and asks a question. The seated monk pauses, considers the question and responds.
This arrangement is inspired by the tradition of Tibetan Buddhist monastic debate, particularly the practice associated with the Gelug school. In this tradition, a standing challenger questions a seated defender. The exchange is a disciplined method of examining arguments, testing assumptions and developing a clearer understanding of Buddhist philosophy.
The clapping is part of the formal practice. It punctuates the questions and arguments; it is not merely a dramatic gesture.
Our conversations borrow this visual arrangement as a literary device. We are not attempting to reproduce the formal rules of Tibetan debate. Instead, we use the two positions to create a space for enquiry: one asks, the other reflects and responds. Both are engaged in learning.
The purpose is not to win an argument. It is to move a little closer to understanding.
The thoughts expressed in these conversations are those of questioning students. They may draw upon traditional teachings, personal understanding, observation and speculation. They are not presented as authoritative interpretations or established philosophical conclusions. Where a thought is a personal musing rather than a recognised teaching, we will identify it as such. Our intention is to keep asking, examining and learning.
Under the tree
The morning was still. A soft breeze moved through the branches, and the leaves cast shifting patterns of light on the ground.
One monk sat beneath the tree, his attention resting quietly within. Another approached, carrying a small notebook.
He stopped a little distance away.
Standing Monk: May I ask you something?
The seated monk looked up and smiled.
Seated Monk: That is usually how a conversation begins. But put away the notebook. Let us converse.
The standing monk smiled too. He placed the notebook in his bag and set it aside. Then he stepped forward and clapped his hands.
Standing Monk: I have been hearing about something called the BMI Chart. What exactly is it? Is it a chart about physical health?
The seated monk paused.
Seated Monk: That is a reasonable first question. The letters BMI may remind you of Body Mass Index, but here they mean something quite different: Body, Mind and Intellect.
Standing Monk: Body, Mind and Intellect. Three familiar words. But why put them together in a chart?
Seated Monk: Because Vedanta asks us to examine how we experience life. We generally say, “I see”, “I feel”, “I think”, and “I act”. But have we ever stopped to examine what is involved in these experiences?
Standing Monk: I see with my eyes. I feel with my mind. I think with my intellect. Is that not enough?
Seated Monk: Let us look more carefully. The body is involved in our physical actions and perceptions. The mind is involved in our feelings and emotions. The intellect helps us reason, discriminate and make decisions. These are different functions, but they work together in our everyday experience.
Standing Monk: So the chart is helping us look at ourselves?
Seated Monk: Yes. It gives us a framework for understanding the equipment through which we experience the world.
Who created the BMI Chart?
Standing Monk: Who put this chart together? Is it an ancient diagram from one of the scriptures?
Seated Monk: The BMI Chart is associated with Pujya Gurudev Swami Chinmayananda, the founder of Chinmaya Mission. He devised it as a way of presenting the ideas of Vedanta in a simpler, more accessible form, and of showing how they relate to everyday life.
Standing Monk: So it is a teaching aid?
Seated Monk: A teaching aid, certainly, but not merely a diagram to memorise. It is an invitation to observe ourselves. The chart helps us ask why we respond differently to the same situation, why we develop particular likes and dislikes, and how our inner tendencies influence our experience.
Standing Monk: That sounds rather practical. Vedanta is often thought of as something abstract and philosophical.
Seated Monk: It can seem that way when we approach it only as a collection of ideas. But the purpose of studying Vedanta is not simply to gather information. It is to enquire into the nature of our experience and, ultimately, our true nature.
What do the letters tell us?
The standing monk took the notebook out of his bag and opened it for reference.
Standing Monk: I have seen a few more letters in the chart. Apart from BMI, there are PFT and OET. What do they mean?
Seated Monk: Let us take them one at a time.
Standing Monk: I am listening.
Seated Monk: PFT stands for Perceiver, Feeler and Thinker. These describe the individual as the experiencer: the one who perceives, feels and thinks.
Standing Monk: And OET?
Seated Monk: Objects, Emotions and Thoughts. They represent the field of our experience.
Standing Monk: Then the chart is connecting the equipment we use with the experiences we have?
Seated Monk: Exactly. The Body, Mind and Intellect are the equipment. Through them, we experience the world as perceivers, feelers and thinkers. Objects, emotions and thoughts form the field in which these experiences take place.
Standing Monk: But surely two people can experience the same object and respond differently?
Seated Monk: Very much so. Two people may see the same painting. One may be delighted; another may feel indifferent. One may remember a pleasant experience, while another may be reminded of something painful.
Standing Monk: The painting has not changed. The people have.
Seated Monk: That is an important observation. The chart encourages us to look beyond the external object and examine the individual responding to it.
And what about V?
The standing monk looked again at his notebook.
Standing Monk: There is one more letter I noticed. V. It stands for Vasanas, does it not?
Seated Monk: Yes. We shall spend an entire conversation exploring Vasanas. For now, let us understand that the chart uses this term for our underlying, unmanifest tendencies and impressions. They influence how we perceive, feel and think.
Standing Monk: So they help explain why we have different preferences and reactions?
Seated Monk: They are an important part of that explanation. But let us not rush. Before we can understand how Vasanas influence the Body, Mind and Intellect, we must first examine what we mean by Vasanas.
Standing Monk: Then I have another question. If these tendencies influence how I experience the world, am I simply at their mercy?
The seated monk remained quiet for a moment.
Seated Monk: That is a question worth keeping. The chart does not merely invite us to identify our tendencies. It also points towards the possibility of understanding and transforming our responses.
Standing Monk: We shall have to return to that.
Seated Monk: We shall.
The standing monk closed his notebook. For a while, neither spoke. The breeze moved through the branches again.
Perhaps the first step in understanding ourselves was simply to begin observing.
What We Have Understood
The BMI Chart offers a framework for looking at human experience through:
- BMI — Body, Mind and Intellect: the equipment through which we experience.
- PFT — Perceiver, Feeler and Thinker: the individual as experiencer.
- OET — Objects, Emotions and Thoughts: the field of experience.
- V — Vasanas: underlying, unmanifest tendencies and impressions.
- OM: the sound-symbol indicating our Real Nature, the Consciousness or Life Principle that enlivens our experience.
The chart is not simply a diagram of separate parts. It helps us examine the relationship between our inner tendencies, the equipment through which we experience life, and the world with which we interact.
A question to carry forward
If our likes, dislikes and habitual responses are influenced by underlying tendencies, where do these tendencies come from?
And can we change them?
That is where our next conversation begins.
Further Reading and Exploration
The BMI Chart and Vedanta
- The BMI Chart — Chinmaya Mission Pittsburgh
An introduction to the chart, its purpose and the relationship between BMI, PFT, OET and Vasanas. - BMI Chart — Chinmaya Mission Ottawa
An explanation of the different elements of the chart, including OM as the symbol of our Real Nature, Consciousness or Life. - The BMI Chart Panel — Chinmaya Mission Mumbai
Further material from Chinmaya Mission on the chart devised by Swami Chinmayananda.
The inspiration behind our conversation format
- Tibetan Buddhist Debate — Tibet House US
An introduction to the challenger and defender, the standing and seated positions, and the role of clapping in Tibetan monastic debate. - Tibetan Monastic Education — University of Virginia, Mandala Collections
A detailed account of monastic education, the structure of debate and the roles of the questioner and defender. - The Meaning of Gestures in Tibetan Buddhist Debate — Tibetan Nuns Project
Explains the gestures used in debate and their traditional symbolic meanings, including the union of wisdom and method. - Fostering Respectful and Productive Conversations: Lessons Learned from Debating Courtyards in Tibetan Buddhist Monasteries — Frontiers in Communication
Explores what the practice of Tibetan monastic debate can teach us about dialogue, listening and examining ideas.
These resources introduce two distinct traditions: the Vedantic teaching framework of the BMI Chart and the Tibetan Buddhist practice of monastic debate. Our series brings them together only as a teaching and storytelling format, not as a claim that they belong to the same philosophical tradition.
Credit: Convo Debate with Goosey (AI Powered ChatGPT).
PS: This is my journey to understand Vedanta through self-questioning using mixed methods.
